Find the Cheap Mackinac Island Hotels

The beautiful hotels don’t even have a bottle of water. The Hilton only had one bottle of mineral water a day for the first two days. You don’t have this at all. You can buy a bottle for $3. If you book for two days, the cleaning on the second day is very sloppy , I almost cleaned up the sheets, the bathroom was not cleaned at all, the external environment is really good, the hotel is too expensive, I suggest you stay in Mackinaw City, and then come directly by boat to play, you can swim with a swimsuit, the water is very clear, and you can play on the island It's all money, just prepare your wallet 😁.

On our anniversary trip to Mackinac Island we stayed at Harbour View Inn. Harbour View Inn is at the quiet end of Main St. and next door to St. Anne's Catholic Church. We stayed in room 3310 in the Guest House. That's the big structure at the back of the property. Room 3310 is a Deluxe Suite 2 Queen/Sofa. The price was just over $500 per night including taxes. The room was very spacious and had a nice water view from a shared balcony. We never had a problem with other guests on the balcony. The grounds are fabulous. Lush flowers are everywhere. They have inexpensive bikes for rent but we didn't ride. There was a Harbor View Inn porter who met us at the ferry dock upon arrival and beat us back to the inn with our bags. On our departure, he took our bags back to the ferry dock. Each morning a continental breakfast was offered in the main building. They have paper plates and plasticware if you want to take it back to your room. Bill's Grill is in front of the main building near the street with grilled food. We ate lunch there one day and it was good. In summary, the location was perfect. The view was incredible. The staff was great. But… The fit and finish sorely failed to make it up to my expectations of a $500 per night hotel. Sink bowl is cracked. Fastener is missing from the light fixture in the bathroom. Paint is peeling on the mirror frame. Caulk is peeling on backsplash. Cabinet doors don't close. Tub/shower is a fiberglass drop-in. Towel bars don't match. Sliding glass door has the lock mechanism removed. Simple hook closure. Sliding screen door on the balcony fell off. The room next door did the same. Supplied iron in the room had an odd plug that wouldn't plug into the wall. A/C is LOUD. Housekeeping didn't always remove dirty bath cloths. I spoke to Michelle at the front desk after our second night and asked for an adjustment. That afternoon maintenance came by and worked on the A/C and cabinet doors. The A/C was much better but the cabinet doors needed much more work. When I got my bill, a $235 credit had been applied lowering the average cost to $434 per night. That was still way too high for the quality of the facility. I wouldn't stay there again.

Breakfast is not the same, bread, juice, boiled eggs, etc., scrambled eggs should be added with 5 knives, but the steak and crab legs for dinner are good! The room is old, ok!

My husband and I traveled to Mackinac Island to celebrate our wedding anniversary and we stayed at The Inn on Mackinac. The Inn was super clean and our room was cozy and it even had a balcony. All the staff was super nice and helpful, and we even received a surprise on the day of our anniversary. They surprised us with delicious fudge and they also helped our family to send us a goodie bag full of delicious things. We liked the beautiful porch and it was very nice that they offer breakfast and there is coffee and tea all day. The Inn is at a great location too. At the same time, it is very quiet and we were able to relax. They also have a little pool-spa, which is very nice to relax. Overall it was a great experience and we hope to go back some other time and stay at the Inn again.

We decided to use St. Ignace as a base for trips to Mackinac Island, Mackinaw City, and various spots in the U.P. We chose Cedar Hill based on other reviews and the location. The room was small. The AC was either freezing or warm; it froze up one day and we were left w no AC at all overnight. I understand many places have shortages with staff and housekeeping. If this were the case, I'm fine if the management let's us know. But, our beds were made only once on the second morning, and only after we inquired. Trash was taken out and we got new towels only after we asked. The breakfast was limited. On our second day there, our keys did not work. They gave us new ones at breakfast. Those didnt work. We walked down,and the front desk gave us new ones. We went back, and they still did not work. My husband called and asked to have someone please come up and fix it, and also open our door. The man came up, looked at it. At first he said the code was reading that our deadbolt was on, but we insisted no one was in the room. He then said that he thought the battery was dead. But, he had to go back, as he didn't have the tools to get us into our room! Over 20 more minutes passed until he came back and got us into our room. We were now delayed close to an hour, and missed an appointment we had made on Mackinac Island! I'm sure you get the point...we were disappointed in our stay. Luckily we were not in the rooms much, but bc of the AC, it was often uncomfortable and hard to sleep.