We loved hotel Presbytere, the staff were so friendly and helpful. Despite the location being in a very busy spot for nightlife (that was still raging on at 6am when we had to leave for our train), we couldn't hear a thing from our room, or even reception!
Our room was a little larger than average (for Paris), and was clean and comfortable.
Things to keep in mind - 1) there is no restaurant/breakfast area, breakfast is delivered to your room each morning and 2) there is no lift, it's an easy walk up to the reception and rooms, however anyone with mobility issues may find this tough.
Overall, we had a lovely time and wouldn't hesitate to recommend this hotel or stay here again!