Gallows Point Resort

We truly enjoyed our stay and can’t wait to come back

Nisha is the absolute best! I have never had an issue with this hotel. The staff is always at the front desk. The site, hotel and rooms are clean. If you love waffles they have a waffle maker, delicious breakfast bar, and coffee station. It is a safe and affordable place to stay.

Staying in Cruz Bay at Wharfside Village (very nice, will give a positive review.). Called Gallows Point to ask if my wife and I could stroll up for a drink in their bar, got a long windy speech about how they normally don’t allow that, but they happen to have some open tables this evening, and might make an exception, but I needed to understand that they really are making a very special accommodation to accept our patronage,. Circular repetitive conversation until I just gave up. Strange way to run a hospitality business.

View

Time for a new toaster. It only heats up the bread. Does not toast. Loved the pool and scenery from our room was perfect! Great time!

This is docJCM again. Back at Gallows Point after at least 6 visits in last 12 years. I have not won the 100 million lottery yet, but I still hope to. Still best place to stay in Cruz Bay. Beautiful views, easy walk to town. We will be back in the future.

The WORLD'S BEST views from: A) the pool area B) the 3rd floor bar at Ocean 362 Restaurant on the premises. Will be back, very soon!!

I am extremely disappointed to have to alert travelers to an overall negative experience I recently had during my stay. Gallows Point has always been an absolute favorite spot of mine for 20+ years. I have stayed more than 10 times in all the different kinds of units and have stayed many times before and after Irma... First of all REFUSE UNITS 8&9. They don't guarantee units, but I would highly advise against these units which I feel should be at a different price point (and nothing at Gallows is actually inexpensive). While all the other units whether harbor side or ocean side are truly water front 9 my previous experience)- these units 8&9 are actually POOL front with a view. The pool has "peaceful pool" rules, and I've always found it tranquil. However, not only do units 8 & 9 have more of an OBSTRUCTED VIEW due to the pool- if the pool is NOT peaceful- neither is your unit and neither is your privacy. When I arrived (holiday week) there were at least 5 children playing loud games, splashing and screaming in the pool (to the point where no other guests could actually even enter the pool). I politely asked for a different unit- any unit (although I paid top holiday dollar for an ocean view upper) and was told with complete disdain "no". I accept that a holiday week might be full but the attitude was actually truly anxiety provoking. After 4 days of no peace at the pool or the unit- I requested that perhaps the management could remind the families of the posted rules. Same rude attitude. The families finally departed, and I asked again to change units as the holiday was over and the resort was much emptier. Again, awful and rude responses. I still love St John. I actually still love Gallows Point- and its great location- yet my sister and our friend- first timers said they'd never come back. Not sure if I will...

The staff was friendly, helpful and welcoming. We felt like family. Til next time.