Hotels in Oyster Bay

Find the Cheap Oyster Bay Hotels

Enter your dates for the latest hotel rates and availability.

Hot travel dates
Today
Tomorrow
This Weekend
Next Weekend
February 2025
  • Mon
  • Tue
  • Wed
  • Thu
  • Fri
  • Sat
  • Sun
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • 16
  • 17
  • 18
  • 19
  • 20
  • 21
  • 22
  • 23
  • 24
  • 25
  • 26
  • 27
  • 28
March 2025
  • Mon
  • Tue
  • Wed
  • Thu
  • Fri
  • Sat
  • Sun
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • 16
  • 17
  • 18
  • 19
  • 20
  • 21
  • 22
  • 23
  • 24
  • 25
  • 26
  • 27
  • 28
  • 29
  • 30
  • 31
Swipe up to view more
Filter by:
Hotel Star Rating
≤2345
Popular Filters
Amazing 4.5+Great 4.0+Good 3.5+Pleasant 3.0+

We found 64 hotels for you in Oyster Bay

Choose your travel dates to see the latest prices and deals.
Most Booked
Lowest Price
Closest to Downtown
Highest Rated
Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham Hotels in Oyster Bay
Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham Hotels in Oyster BayViana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
Thank you for choosing our Trademark Hotel Collection property. Enjoying a warm welcome. Savoring a perfect pour. Sinking into plush bedding. A serene stay with a Wyndham Hotels and Resorts property make up the moments that create memories to last a lifetime.
Very Good
99 reviews
4.1/5
Price from
CAD 208
per night
Check Availability
Inn at Jericho Hotels in Oyster Bay
Inn at Jericho Hotels in Oyster BayInn at Jericho Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
CC 2021.06.09
Nice and updated good for exactly what you need it for sleep ,eat and to shower/bathe! It was a quick 2nights.Beds were comfortable and clean as well! Service was decent a little misunderstanding but we worked it out.
102 reviews
3.8/5
Price from
CAD 151
per night
Check Availability
Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island Hotels in Oyster Bay
Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island Hotels in Oyster BayComfort Inn Syosset-Long Island Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
GGuest User 2023.06.17
This was an excellent choice for my friend and me. We had a room with 2 double beds. The bed was comfortable, the bathroom shower was excellent. The hotel was very quiet. Since I have to eat gluten free, there weren't alot of choices for breakfast but the eggs, fruit and oatmeal were good. The staff were all friendly and so helpful. I enjoyed being able to sit in the area near the amazing fish tank and charge my phone while reading or eating. The front desk person who was on duty on Saturday morning, June 10 deserves a special shout out. My friend and I were in a serious car crash when leaving the hotel and the manager couldn't have been more kind and caring. We sat in the hotel lobby for hours collecting ourselves and figuring out transportation. Again, the desk clerk offered us water, asked if we wanted anything to eat, kept an eye on us and made us feel cared for. I am sorry I didn't get his name but he deserves to be recognized for the kindness he showed us.
Very Good
101 reviews
4.0/5
Price from
CAD 169
per night
Check Availability
Oyster Bay
You Might Like
Hotels With BreakfastHotels With Twin RoomHotels With 1 Double BedHotels With Swimming PoolHotels With Free Cancellation
Econo Lodge Hotels in Oyster Bay
Econo Lodge Hotels in Oyster BayEcono Lodge Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
GGuest User 2022.08.18
Very nice job on the renovation since we’ve been here last. Clean & Comfortable rooms with updates throughout. Staff is friendly and great location what more could you ask for. We plan on staying here again !
Very Good
103 reviews
4.1/5
Price from
CAD 156
per night
Check Availability
Days Inn by Wyndham Hicksville Long Island Hotels in Oyster Bay
Days Inn by Wyndham Hicksville Long Island Hotels in Oyster BayDays Inn by Wyndham Hicksville Long Island Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
GGuest User 2022.06.27
good customer service Helpful staff, room was small, hey but you get what you paid for no complaints front desk person polite and nice room was cleaned every day i stayed will definitely recommend friends and family Room was clean. TV worked with list of channels available on handy printout. Ironing board and iron available. hot water for tea (BIG PLUS!) and some breakfast items available .Bed was comfortable We were able to park close to our room.
98 reviews
3.0/5
Price from
CAD 156
per night
Check Availability
Extended Stay America Suites - Long Island - Bethpage Hotels in Oyster Bay
Extended Stay America Suites - Long Island - Bethpage Hotels in Oyster BayExtended Stay America Suites - Long Island - Bethpage Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
GGuest User 2022.06.22
This is a hotel to avoid. There are numerous maintenance and management issues with this property. It started with the elevator to our room, which probably needs to have a NY State inspection. The hydraulic system causes shuddering going up and down, which seems like a hydraulic valve issue—scary. Then try and find room 212. One sign says rooms 210 to 219 go left. The other sign says 208 - 201 go right? Designed by math majors? The room we found was not completely clean, and though there is a kitchenette, there are no useful appliances like a coffee maker or any cups, plates, etc. You have to request these items. You also have to request a change of towels or room services unless you wait 7 days. There may be a charge if you need something sooner. The finish in the tub shower is peeling off, and everything in the room exudes a shabby feel.. the property needs some TLC. They advertise on Booking that breakfast is included, but what they have is crappy lukewarm coffee, a plastic wrapped muffin, and very skimpy nature valley granola bits—like mini bars. They have oatmeal packets but there is only hot water and sugar to add, and no bowl to mix it in, and no salt if you don’t want sweet oatmeal.. This was a complete rip-off at over $300 a night. I would NEVER EVER stay here again and advise all to look elsewhere. Terrible.
86 reviews
3.1/5
Price from
CAD 193
per night
Check Availability
The Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel Hotels in Oyster Bay
The Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel Hotels in Oyster BayThe Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
2024.05.23
The Inn at Fox Hollow was a great place for a mid-week staycation. They have lovely grounds (not surprising this this is a wedding destination). The heated pool and hot tub very lovely and open until 8 pm. The room fee includes a free dinner buffet (mid-week only) and free breakfast. The dinner theme was Memorial Day barbecue. Breakfast was even better, with everything you could want to eat in the morning. The room was very large with a king sized bed, living room with sofa bed and a kitchenette The staff was very helpful, too. The Inn at Fox Hollow can be very busy with weddings so we would definitely go back for a mid-week stay.
Excellent
103 reviews
4.4/5
Price from
CAD 233
per night
Check Availability
Best Western Woodbury Inn Hotels in Oyster Bay
Best Western Woodbury Inn Hotels in Oyster BayBest Western Woodbury Inn Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
GGuest User 2021.10.19
I made the mistake of booking this hotel for my entire family & bridal party. Everything they told us was a lie. This place looks like the motel that my friends & I used to have hotel parties at when I was a teenager. The furniture was scratched, old, & looks like it came from a garage sale. Every room had an odor, things were broken in each room, everybody was having issues.The worst part of all of this is that there was construction at the hotel. My now husband & I had driven down Jericho turnpike a few weeks prior to our wedding. I noticed a construction site in front of the hotel. We called asked if this was affecting the property in any way shape or form. We were reassured that there was no construction on the property at all . When we arrived, the parking lot was dirt, rocks, caution tape everywhere. No pavement. The big beautiful tree in the front of the hotel is ripped out & there’s temporary construction fencing, rocks, dirt & caution tape right in front. I had guests dressed for a formal wedding in heels gowns suits&tuxedos tracking through this.They also told us that hot breakfast was serve every day. Which is half true. When I asked if it was just package foods like muffins & granola bars they said “no it’s fresh made to order food that can be either delivered to the room ,picked up or eaten in the lobby.” Breakfast was basically like Jimmy Dean style egg sandwich wrap and placed in heater & microwavable pancakes. The lobby is a joke. Maybe eight people can sit comfortably to eat, And that’s being generous. I will say, they had juice water coffee, a very nice tea selection available 24/7. We were also told the the hotel provides shuttle service to any stores or destinations within five miles of the property, as well as pick ups and drop offs to the train station. Nope. Not one employee knew anything about this. Apparently, it is an imaginary shuttle. So there’s that. Although The girls at the hotel are very sweet, everyone was full of excuses as to why service was slow, etc. My mother-in-law and Aunt were splitting the cost of the room. When they went to pay, The guy at the front desk told them that they could not split it on two separate cards because his system didn’t work that way. Really? As a bride, i was hysterically crying on my wedding day absolutely mortified. We had guests from all over the country at the is place. I’ve never been so embarrassed in my entire life. This is The Worst Place Ever
102 reviews
3.5/5
Price from
CAD 146
per night
Check Availability
Days Inn by Wyndham Woodbury Long Island Hotels in Oyster Bay
Days Inn by Wyndham Woodbury Long Island Hotels in Oyster BayDays Inn by Wyndham Woodbury Long Island Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
2019.03.21
The location of the hotel is very good, the next high speed is seen without turning, the room is very comfortable. The breakfast category is quite rich, and every time I come to Long Island, I live here. And there are several commercial plazas on the opposite side, and eating is convenient.
102 reviews
3.3/5
Price from
CAD 115
per night
Check Availability
Holiday Inn Plainview-Long Island Hotels in Oyster Bay
Holiday Inn Plainview-Long Island Hotels in Oyster BayHoliday Inn Plainview-Long Island Hotels in Oyster Bay
Hotel near Oyster Bay
GGuest User 2022.08.12
Our stay at this hotel was the most pleasant of all the hotels we stayed at in NY (we stayed at 3 different ones). The hotel was very, very clean and we enjoyed our stay of two days. We were on the first floor (which when we got there we had asked to move from the third floor they had originally booked us in and they changed the room without any hesitation to accommodate our request) which we were able to drive around the side of the hotel and enter right from the parking lot...loved this! The outdoor pool was wonderful... lounge chairs around it for relaxing after a swim. There was tables just outside the pool area with canopies to get relief from the hot sun and to have a drink...very nice spot. There was a restaurant/ bar right in the hotel which seemed busy all the time it was open. We really enjoyed the pizza from this spot! One thing I absolutely loved about this hotel was the shower! The best shower I had in a long time...lots of water pressure and no shortage of hot water. The shampoo, conditioner and body wash supplied was Dove and large pump bottles not the tiny little bottles usually found in other hotels. Dove pump to wash your hands at the sink and Dove pump Body Lotion. The staff were very friendly and accommodating... just a great vibe there. In the front of the building there is a small waterfall on rocks surrounded by bushes and a bench across from it to sit.. was very pretty in the evening. I would not hesitate to stay at this hotel again if visiting this area!
Very Good
119 reviews
4.2/5
Price from
CAD 192
per night
Check Availability
See All Hotels in Oyster Bay

Latest Reviews for Oyster Bay hotels

See all
Explore genuine reviews and ratings from real travellers to find the perfect accommodation for your needs.
3.9/5
This property has both inside ”hotel” rooms and outside ”motel” rooms which was not made very clear when we booked. We paid extra for a ”deluxe” room - it was inside, it had a lot of space, but nothing fancy. Small fridge. It was clean enough. Our big issue was that our AC was leaking throughout our stay and it never got truly fixed despite their attempts. The breakfast was just ok. The indoor pool was clean enough, but COLD. Another member of my family had an outside room that smelled terribly of mold/mildew. This is definitely better than a lot of the alternatives, but I feel it should have been even better for the high price they charge.
Best Western Bar Harbour Inn Hotels in Oyster Bay

Best Western Bar Harbour Inn

Hotel near Oyster Bay
Price per night from:CAD 197
3.2/5
TTourist21692264945Outside unkempt with an empty bottle and cans around the ”firepit” Check-in office stank of garlic/food and shelves and floors covered with random ”stuff”. Checked in by a scruffy man, who was actually sitting in the middle of the room, eating food from a plastic container balanced on a chair. No hello, please or thank you. The photographs show a Mexican restaurant onsite - there is not. The rooms the restaurant may have been in are locked with dark window coverings. Given a key, drove round to the first room allocated - right at the far end of the building, very dark entryway, under the fire escape. Opened the door to find a pitch black room with the light switch located on another wall (not by the door). Light dim. Room smelt musty and looked grubby. Back to the office to complain. Given another key to a different room - strangely this key had five different, old key fobs on it, mostly broken(??!!). Off to the second room - again, pitch black inside with the light switch on another wall - had to leave the door open to find the switch.. Light dim - found two more lights to put on. Still pretty dark. A very small, dirty window covered by a huge blanket (yes, blanket!) nailed to the wall, this blanket was covered by two sets of curtains - weird. The blanket hung almost to the floor and covered the aircon unit which was stuffed into the wall and held in place with protruding foam strips and duct tape. The main door entrance threshold was unfinished and dirty and there was a small hole in the bottom of the door. This door was damaged and dirty. The smoke alarm was actually chained to the wall and not on the ceiling. Old baseboard heating system that was falling apart and rusting. Loose wires/cables trailing on the floor. Circular table with broken legs/stand repaired (?) with decorators tape. Ceiling tiles coming away from the walls and ceiling, some held in place with clear sticky tape and some stained. Dirty cobwebs in the corners of the room.. Down the side of the TV (which was reasonably new) the cables were, again, trailing on the floor. The remote control was not clean. No tea/coffee facilities. No iron/ironing board. Bathroom/toilet - so small that the door almost touched the hand basin when open. The door and frame were badly damaged. There had been a door on the toilet area but that was gone. In the toilet area there was, again, baseboard heating that had fallen apart and was rusting. The walls were dirty and marked. The grouting around the bathtub was jagged and unclean. The shower head looked nasty! No hairdryer (although it is shown in the website photos as having them in the bathrooms). Free internet access is advertised - there was none. I couldn't even get a decent signal on my phone. Got in my car to see if there were any alternatives in the local area - the only thing I found was a Dog Hotel & Spa - in retrospect I would probably have been better checking in there - lol - it couldn't have be
Tides Inn at Stehli Beach Hotels in Oyster Bay

Tides Inn at Stehli Beach

Hotel near Oyster Bay
Price per night from:CAD 98

FAQs About Hotels in Oyster Bay

What are the most popular hotels in Oyster Bay?

There are many popular options for hotels in Oyster Bay. Whether you're traveling for business or a vacation, Best Western Bar Harbour Inn, Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham and Tides Inn at Stehli Beach are popular choices.

What is the average price for hotels in Oyster Bay?

The average price for hotels in Oyster Bay is CAD 268 for weekdays, and CAD 393 for weekends (Friday–Saturday).

What are popular hotels with high-quality breakfasts in Oyster Bay?

Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham and Best Western Bar Harbour Inn are popular hotels with high-quality breakfast. Start your wonderful journey with tasty breakfast!

What hotels in Oyster Bay offer airport shuttle?

Are you worried about transportation in Oyster Bay? Viana Hotel and Spa and Trademark Collection by Wyndham is a popular hotel providing airport transfer services.

What are available deals for hotels in Oyster Bay?

There are multiple promotions and discounts all year round for Trip.com users . Please check the promotions page to see what promotions are available now on Trip.com.

Which hotels with fitness facilities in Oyster Bay are popular?

Best Western Bar Harbour Inn, Viana Hotel and Spa and Trademark Collection by Wyndham are popular hotels with a fitness center. Keep your fitness plan during traveling from Trip.com!

Which popular hotels in Oyster Bay offer free Wi-Fi ?

Whether you're traveling on business or for vacation, internet connection is an essential facility. Best Western Bar Harbour Inn, Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham and Tides Inn at Stehli Beach are popular hotels with free Wi-Fi.

Which hotels in Oyster Bay have swimming pools?

Best Western Bar Harbour Inn, Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham and Tides Inn at Stehli Beach provide awesome swimming pools. Book now and enjoy your swimming pool!

What are the best sap hotels in Oyster Bay?

A spa treatment can be the perfect way to unwind after a long day of travel. Viana Hotel and Spa and Trademark Collection by Wyndham provides wonderful spa services.

Oyster Bay Hotels Information

Highest PriceCAD 1,098
Lowest PriceCAD 98
Number of Reviews396
Total Properties10
Average Price (Weekdays)CAD 268
Average Price (Weekends)CAD 393