Trip.com
>
Hotels
>
Hotels in United States
>
Hotels in New York State
>
Hotels in Fire Island

Best Hotels in Fire Island

Explore Fire Island hotels and choose from 10 properties near landmarks, luxury hotels, and top boutiques for the best shopping and dining.

Grove Hotel
9.4 (100 reviews)

Grove Hotel ★★

📍 1 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove, Fire Island

"Excellent stay at the Grove, early check in was must appreciated. Across the pool from the Ice Palace and steps from the beach. Clean spacious rooms. Relatively quiet on the no pool side. Could do with flexible shower hose in bathroom"

1 night CAD 214
Book Now
Beautiful Ocean Park Family Vacation Rental
10 (24 reviews)

Beautiful Ocean Park Family Vacation Rental ★★★★

📍 Fire Island

Book Now
Pristine 7BR 4.5BA house w/ heated Pool at Fire Island Pines 500' to ocean
10 (4 reviews)

Pristine 7BR 4.5BA house w/ heated Pool at Fire Island Pines 500' to ocean ★★★★

📍 Fire Island

Book Now
Paradise on the Great South Bay
10 (4 reviews)

Paradise on the Great South Bay ★★★★

📍 Fire Island

Book Now
Oceanfront renovated home in FI Pines, stunning views & spacious outdoor oasis
10 (5 reviews)

Oceanfront renovated home in FI Pines, stunning views & spacious outdoor oasis ★★★★

📍 Fire Island

Book Now
AIR CONDITIONED 4 Bed/2 Bath Beach House
10 (26 reviews)

AIR CONDITIONED 4 Bed/2 Bath Beach House ★★★

📍 Fire Island

Book Now
Unbelievable October Deals - Booking Through 10/31/26
10 (21 reviews)

Unbelievable October Deals - Booking Through 10/31/26 ★★★

📍 Fire Island

Book Now
Ocean Bay Park Sanctuary
10 (34 reviews)

Ocean Bay Park Sanctuary ★★★★

📍 Fire Island

Book Now
Gatsby’s Main Level. Ocean Bay Park. Heated Saltwater Pool + Hot Tub. Sleeps 14
10 (6 reviews)

Gatsby’s Main Level. Ocean Bay Park. Heated Saltwater Pool + Hot Tub. Sleeps 14 ★★★★

📍 Fire Island

Book Now
See All Hotels in Fire Island

Guest Reviews on Fire Island Hotels

10.0
Excellent Community Rating
Real & verified guest reviews from around the world
G

GB Guest User

Solo traveler
Grove Hotel ★★
"Excellent stay at the Grove, early check in was must appreciated. Across the pool from the Ice Palace and steps from the beach. Clean spacious rooms. Relatively quiet on the no pool side. Could do with flexible shower hose in bathroom"
★★★★★
2026-09-16

Fire Island Travel Information

⚡

Power Plug & Voltage

120V/Type A/B

💵

Exchange Rate

1 CAD ≈ 0.71 USD

💳

Local Payment

Cards/ApplePay/Cash

📱

Connectivity

Verizon/AT&T/T-Mobile

🌡️

Current Weather

Cloudy

More Information About Fire Island Hotels

Key Info

Details

Number of reviews

120

Total properties

10

Weekday Avg. Price

CAD 294

Weekend Avg. Price

CAD 315

Trending hotel

Grove Hotel

FAQs About Hotels in Fire Island

  • What are the most popular hotels in Fire Island?

    There are many popular options for hotels in Fire Island. Whether you're traveling for business or a vacation, Grove Hotel (from CAD 201) is a good choice.

  • What is the average price for hotels in Fire Island?

    The average price for hotels in Fire Island is CAD 294 for weekdays, and CAD 315 for weekends (Friday–Saturday).

  • What are available deals for hotels in Fire Island?

    There are multiple promotions and discounts all year round for Trip.com users . Please check the promotions page to see what promotions are available now on Trip.com.

  • Which popular hotels in Fire Island offer free Wi-Fi ?

    Whether you're traveling on business or for vacation, internet connection is an essential facility. Grove Hotel (from CAD 201) is a popular hotel with free Wi-Fi.

  • Which hotels in Fire Island have swimming pools?

    Grove Hotel (from CAD 201) provides a good swimming pool. Book now and enjoy your swimming pool!

Find Great Travel Deals & Explore Destinations on Trip.com

Disclaimer: This article has been provided by an individual contributor or third party platform. If there is any discrepancy regarding the copyright, please contact us directly and we will delete the content immediately.